Rules, appropriate actions and karmic consequences

by David Lourie, cartoonist and creator of Dharma The Cat, The Buddhist Channel, Sept 26, 2007

The current cartoon (in Dharma the Cat) is about "Rules," which raises the question of whether the aggressively protesting Buddhist monks in Burma,
whose conduct could be deemed to be "harmful" to some, are acting contrary
to the Buddhist rule (precept) of Right Conduct.

They could also be seen as being attached to the outcome of their efforts, which is contrary to the Buddhist rule of Right Thought.

Here are my own thoughts on this.

On the one hand, there are "official" Buddhist guidelines to Right Conduct that prohibit monks from doing any harmful behaviour to other sentient beings, upon penalty of harmful karmic consequences.  These guidelines do not allow any exceptions, for whatever special reasons that might prevail, even like the cruel political regime which now rules Burma with an iron fist.  The rule of non-attachment also allow for no exceptions -- for example, you must not even remain attached to the goal of enlightenment.

On the other hand, there is the Principle of the Greater Good.  My information from the Jataka stories is that in a previous life, the Buddha killed a pirate on board a ship, because the pirate was planning to sink the ship and kill the passengers, and the Buddha's compassion for the man's karmic fate was so great that he was willing to take on the act of killing, and the karmic consequences that go with it, in service of the greater good. And my understanding is that because karma is determined by intention, the Buddha's seemingly aggressively harmful act was actually beneficial, from a karmic point of view, because his intention was pure, so he escaped harmful karmic consequences from harming a sentient being -- and thus demonstrated a valid exception to the "rules."

On the third hand, according to my own limited understanding, the very idea that a sentient being exists and can be harmed is fundamentally contrary to the principle that the existence of a sentient being is an illusory mental formulation based on Wrong View.

So where does all that leave us ordinary illusory sentient beings who are in search of guidelines?

The rules of behaviour for monks were formulated by the Buddha in a highly political context, in which he and his followers were completely dependent upon the generosity of local villagers, so conduct was important not only in a karmic sense for spiritual development, but also in a political sense, to keep the villagers on side for the physical sustenance and survival of the

So it seems to me that the significance of the Burmese monks' conduct must be evaluated separately and independently by two entirely different standards -- the karmic standard, and the Buddhist institutional standard.

The karmic significance of each Burmese monk's conduct depends entirely upon each individual's intention, which would undoubtedly be coloured and flavoured differently in each case by a unique blend of emotional and psychological ingredients, leaving different monks with different "ratings" on the purity of intention scale.

So I think whether the monks' conduct is appropriate in karmic terms is really an issue of individual conscience, not group "rules."

On the other hand (I've lost count), I am proposing this even though their conduct may be deemed not appropriate in terms of Buddhist institutional rules -- ie, what's appropriate in order for them to remain an upstanding member of the Buddhist sangha.

We Need Your Help to Train the
Buddhist AI Chat Bot
(Neural Operator for Responsible Buddhist Understanding)

For Malaysians and Singaporeans, please make your donation to the following account:

Account Name: Bodhi Vision
Account No:. 2122 00000 44661
Bank: RHB

The SWIFT/BIC code for RHB Bank Berhad is: RHBBMYKLXXX
Address: 11-15, Jalan SS 24/11, Taman Megah, 47301 Petaling Jaya, Selangor
Phone: 603-9206 8118

Note: Please indicate your name in the payment slip. Thank you.

Dear Friends in the Dharma,

We seek your generous support to help us train NORBU, the word's first Buddhist AI Chat Bot.

Here are some ways you can contribute to this noble cause:

One-time Donation or Loan: A single contribution, regardless of its size, will go a long way in helping us reach our goal and make the Buddhist LLM a beacon of wisdom for all.

How will your donation / loan be used? Download the NORBU White Paper for details.

For Malaysians and Singaporeans, please make your donation to the following account:

Account Name: Bodhi Vision
Account No:. 2122 00000 44661
Bank: RHB

The SWIFT/BIC code for RHB Bank Berhad is: RHBBMYKLXXX
Address: 11-15, Jalan SS 24/11, Taman Megah, 47301 Petaling Jaya, Selangor
Phone: 603-9206 8118

Note: Please indicate your purpose of payment (loan or donation) in the payment slip. Thank you.

Once payment is banked in, please send the payment slip via email to: Your donation/loan will be published and publicly acknowledged on the Buddhist Channel.

Spread the Word: Share this initiative with your friends, family and fellow Dharma enthusiasts. Join "Friends of Norbu" at: Together, we can build a stronger community and create a positive impact on a global scale.

Volunteer: If you possess expertise in AI, natural language processing, Dharma knowledge in terms of Buddhist sutras in various languages or related fields, and wish to lend your skills, please contact us. Your knowledge and passion could be invaluable to our project's success.

Your support is part of a collective effort to preserve and disseminate the profound teachings of Buddhism. By contributing to the NORBU, you become a "virtual Bodhisattva" to make Buddhist wisdom more accessible to seekers worldwide.

Thank you for helping to make NORBU a wise and compassionate Buddhist Chatbot!

May you be blessed with inner peace and wisdom,

With deepest gratitude,

Kooi F. Lim
On behalf of The Buddhist Channel Team

Note: To date, we have received the following contributions for NORBU:
US$ 75 from Gary Gach (Loan)
US$ 50 from Chong Sim Keong
MYR 300 from Wilson Tee
MYR 500 from Lim Yan Pok
MYR 50 from Oon Yeoh
MYR 200 from Ooi Poh Tin
MYR 300 from Lai Swee Pin
MYR 100 from Ong Hooi Sian
MYR 1,000 from Fam Sin Nin
MYR 500 from Oh teik Bin
MYR 300 from Yeoh Ai Guat
MYR 300 from Yong Lily
MYR 50 from Bandar Utama Buddhist Society
MYR 1,000 from Chiam Swee Ann
MYR 1,000 from Lye Veei Chiew
MYR 1,000 from Por Yong Tong
MYR 80 from Lee Wai Yee
MYR 500 from Pek Chee Hen
MYR 300 from Hor Tuck Loon
MYR 1,000 from Wise Payments Malaysia Sdn Bhd
MYR 200 from Teo Yen Hua
MYR 500 from Ng Wee Keat
MYR 10,000 from Chang Quai Hung, Jackie (Loan)
MYR 10,000 from K. C. Lim & Agnes (Loan)
MYR 10,000 from Juin & Jooky Tan (Loan)
MYR 100 from Poh Boon Fong (on behalf of SXI Buddhist Students Society)
MYR 10,000 from Fam Shan-Shan (Loan)
MYR 10,000 from John Fam (Loan)
MYR 500 from Phang Cheng Kar
MYR 100 from Lee Suat Yee
MYR 500 from Teo Chwee Hoon (on behalf of Lai Siow Kee)
MYR 200 from Mak Yuen Chau

We express our deep gratitude for the support and generosity.

If you have any enquiries, please write to: